Showing posts with label Israel/Palestine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Israel/Palestine. Show all posts

Sunday, January 18, 2009

Ceasefire in Gaza

Obama knows better and the Israeli political class knows that he knows better, though he may not be able to do much about it – unless he turns out to possess a virtue that is all but unknown among Democrats, courage. Throughout the campaign there was little sign of it; in the transition period, there has been none at all. Still, the Israelis realize that, no matter how good (for them) Obama turns out to be, they’ll never have had it so good as under W. Dimwit Bush. So they’re treading (somewhat) lightly, for the time being. It is Obama’s inauguration that accounts for the unilateral ceasefire Israel just announced. Neither morality nor even elementary decency has anything to do with; and neither do Israel’s strategic objectives towards the other parties involved – whether they be Palestinian, Lebanese, Syrian, Egyptian, or Iranian.

Of course, a cease fire with the (re)occupiers in place is bound to be fragile, especially if Hamas has no interest of its own, at this point, in observing it. [Saving the people who elected them to office from Israeli murder and mayhem has never been a high priority for Hamas. Maybe, though, they too will want to make a peace offering to the new President.] Nevertheless, if Israel is lucky, it will be able to present itself as the peacemaker – for at least a short while. The Israelis know they can count on servile Western media to help them present that (transparently false) image. They also know that the media that matters most (for them), American media, are nothing if not servile (and gullible and morally corrupt), especially where Israel is concerned.

What is absolutely clear is that, as in Lebanon in 2006, all the killing and maiming and infrastructure destruction accomplished none of Israel’s declared aims. No doubt, Hamas’s military capabilities, never much to worry about, have been somewhat “degraded.” But Hamas can still fire rockets into southern Israel whenever it pleases. Much as Hezbollah did in 2006, Hamas “won” if only by surviving. Correspondingly, Israel “lost” by demonstrating again that its overwhelming military superiority is a paper tiger – of little or no use in the circumstances it confronts.

But, of course, Israel’s declared aims were never its real aims. Everything Israel has done to Gaza in recent years, including its vaunted “withdrawal” in 2005, has had the same aim: to drive a wedge between Fatah and Hamas, helping to insure that the Palestinians who cannot be driven out of Greater Israel will have no viable political leadership capable of countering Israeli dominance.

[Sadly, both Fatah and Hamas have been more than a little complicitous in this Israeli endeavor. Indeed, from the time the Palestinian national movement coalesced in the 1960s, the Palestinians have been spectacularly unsuccessful in building institutions capable of running a viable state. In this respect, the contrast with the pre-1948 Jewish minority in Palestine is striking.]

Israel’s assault on Gaza was part of its on-going project of “dividing and conquering” the Palestinian national movement. Israel took some hits this time around, as it did in Lebanon in 2006, but, in view of its real aims, it hardly “lost” categorically. Its goal – an ethnically “pure” Jewish state in as much of Mandate Palestine as it can obtain and hold – is still very much on track. So too, despite its military setback, is its ambition to become the hegemonic power in a militarily and politically fragmented region.

[Recall that, despite its crushing technological advantages, the United States “lost” militarily even more spectacularly in Vietnam. But if the real aim was to block what Noam Chomsky calls “the threat of a good example” – economic, political and social development outside the American ambit – it’s far from clear who lost.]

Anyway, before long, perhaps even from the get go, Obama will have to deal with Israel’s ethnic cleansing of Palestinians – from Gaza, and from “Judea and Samaria” (the Occupied West Bank) as well. Because Israel is able to get away with its depredations thanks mainly to American largesse, Obama could stop it on a dime. He knows he should. But he also knows that, if he tries, he won’t still have 80% of Americans rooting for him; he knows that the Israel lobby will fight him tooth and nail. Will he have the courage to do the right thing – to do what will benefit both America and even Israel (in the long run) most? It’s not yet certain that he won’t, but it’s plainly unlikely. That’s the shadow that hangs over the impending and “inspiring” Martin Luther King - Inauguration Day celebrations.

Monday, January 12, 2009

Abject and Servile, Part 2

All the Senate Democrats, indeed all the Senators, voted last week for a resolution according essentially unconditional support for the on-going Israeli atrocities in Gaza. The House of Representatives has now followed suit. Here in the Home of the Brave, only five representatives had the courage to vote No: Dennis Kucinich (OH), of course, and three other Democrats -- Maxine Waters (CA), Gwen Moore (WI), and Nick Rahall (WV). They were joined by the one real “maverick” in the Republican Party, Ron Paul (TX).

Twenty-two other Democrats voted “present”; so much for the vaunted “Progressive” Caucus to which most of these cowards belong. The ones who voted “present” include Raul Grijalva (AZ), Sam Farr (CA), Barbara Lee (CA), George Miller (CA), Loretta Sanchez (CA), Pete Stark (CA), Diane Watson (CA), Lynn Woolsey (CA), Hank Johnson (GA), Neil Abercrombie (HI), John Dingell (MI), Carolyn Kilpatrick (MI), Keith Ellison (MN), Betty McCollum (MI), Earl Blumenauer (OR), Pete DeFazio (OR), Donna Edwards (MD), John Olver (MA), Donal Payne (NJ), Maurice Hinchey (NY), Jim Moran (VA), and Jim McDermott (WA).

The rest, including many prominent and ostensibly “progressive” members of the Black Caucus, couldn’t even find it within themselves to rise to the level of cowardice.



.

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Abject and Servile

That should be the motto of the U.S. Senate which today voted unanimously to endorse Israeli depravity in Gaza. [Killing women and children who had taken refuge in a UN school, and a UN worker driving a truck to pick up supplies for Gaza’s starving population are just the latest atrocities.] Moral cretinism is evidently the only real requirement for Senate membership. Yet they question whether Roland Burris or anyone else appointed by Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich might be unfit to sit among them -- because Blagojevich is “tainted”!

Monday, January 5, 2009

When the Lesser Evil Party is Not a Lesser Evil

As happens when Israel “acts out,” there is little to do but despair. So much injustice, so little resistance – not among the world’s peoples, including the American people, many of whom evidently know better – but among governments and the media that serve them. As usual, the U.S. is First Among Scoundrels.

[In fairness, our media have reported on “civilian casualties” and they have run comments from people on “the other side.” Being “fair and balanced,” however, those who dare utter obvious but politically inadmissible assessments are without fail balanced by interviews with Israeli government officials or other apologists for Israel. One can only wonder – would they have covered the Warsaw Ghetto uprising in a similarly fair and balanced way?]

Thus the Bush government blocked a Security Council resolution this weekend calling for a cease-fire in Gaza. [With just two more weeks of Cheney/Bush rule, one can only hope that this was their last egregious crime!] There was hardly a peep of dissent from within our political class. Our “liberals” especially, Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reed along with other Lesser Evil Party luminaries, have offered unqualified support to Israel and Bush. Their abject servility to the Israel lobby probably makes little difference in this instance, however; after all, no country disregards international public opinion – and international law – with the wanton brazenness of the state of Israel. And why not, with the U.S. giving them all the “get out of jail free” cards they could possibly want!

This leaves “us” with little to do except despair over our impotence. In our “democracy,” we have no means of political expression. In this case, even more than in the days before Bush launched his war against Iraq, Democrats, almost without exception (Dennis Kucinich is always an exception), are unwilling to offer even mute opposition. All we can do, alas, is write for each other -- in the hope that some of it will find its way to a larger (already overwhelmingly sympathetic) audience. There’s been a lot of that in the past few days. Some of the preaching to the converted (and a few others?) has been excellent. For context, a concept all but unknown in our media, see, for example, Robert Perry’s piece in AlterNet.org, “The Long and Bloody Hypocrisy of U.S. Acts of Terrorism.” Glenn Greenwald’s latest in salon.com, “Orwell, Blinding Tribalism, Selective Terroism and Israel/Gaza” offers fresh insights – particularly on the remarkable, but entirely predictable, phenomenon of “liberal” support for Israel’s latest aggression.

I have one other reading recommendation: Henry Siegman’s “The Last Chance at Middle East Peace” in the January 12 Nation. Siegman, a former national director of the American Jewish Congress and of the Synagogue Council of America, has been arguing for years about the need for the U.S. to force Israel to act in its own interest by accepting the so-called Clinton Parameters of December 2000, as elaborated at Taba in January 2001. Siegman thinks that time is running out: that Israeli settlements on the West Bank have all but made a two state “solution” impossible, and that if Obama doesn’t act decisively within the next year or so, the chances for any durable two state solution will be irreversibly lost. The events of the past few days in Gaza make his argument even more compelling.

I am not an unequivocal supporter of a two-state solution: I think that, in light of the advances registered in the American and French Revolutions, the idea of an ethnic and/or confessional state is atavistic. And I find the idea of ethnic cleansing, the principle upon which the state of Israel exists, repellent. On the other hand, given the state of opinion among all the interested parties, there seems to be no other way to arrive at a lasting peace.

Will Obama rise to the occasion? It’s not quite yet time to abandon all hope, but the prospects are dim. That’s why it surely is time to begin to plan strategies, enlisting the large numbers of Americans who don’t buy the Israel can do no wrong line of our political class --especially those of us Chosen folks who can rise above ethnic chauvinism -- into something like the grass-roots, civil society struggles that helped bring down Apartheid in South Africa. With so many powerful forces mobilized against justice, it will be harder this time to launch boycotts and to promote divestment; and, needless to say, getting the U.S. government to agree to sanctions is all but out of the question. In view of how utterly dependent Israel is on U.S. support, if sanctions were politically possible they would be unnecessary. But, with or without Obama’s aid, Israel must be stopped! It is necessary for national and international security; and, even were it not, the victims of the Israeli occupation deserve at least a semblance of justice. Now is therefore the time to ponder how to proceed – and how to integrate that struggle into the broader struggle in and over our despicably abject Lesser Evil Party.

Saturday, January 3, 2009

What Is It Good For?

As was all but inevitable once Israeli planes began the wanton destruction of Gaza, Israel has launched a ground assault; it has made the transition from Clinton (kill only from the air) to Bush (kill from everywhere). It is certain that, as in Lebanon, the Israelis will indeed kill a lot of people, maim even more, and destroy much of what is left of critical infrastructure. It is very nearly as certain that the Israeli “Defense” Force will, again as in Lebanon, suffer significant casualties and accomplish none of its declared aims. This is good news in a way: Israel will again be humiliated. It would be even better news if the Israeli political class – left, right and center -- had the capacity to learn from its mistakes.

Meanwhile, there is nothing from the Bush government except support for the aggressor, while the Mubarak regime in Egypt continues to collaborate with Israel and the United States. It will probably not remain able to resist public opinion for long. Paradoxically, the Americans and Israelis had better hope it does not. If Mubarak continues to be America’s and Israel’s stooge, his government is likely to fall. Then Israel could be facing a far graver threat than a few homemade rockets lobbed at its southern cities. This plain truth is probably beyond the capacity of anybody in the Bush administration to understand. It is therefore not surprising that they are uninterested in stopping the killing. But what were the Israelis thinking? They know what’s what. Don’t they care that, even before they started this war, Mubarak was holding on by the skin of his teeth, sustained only by a brutal apparatus of police repression and American aid? Or does that worry pale before the electoral machinations of Tzipi Livni and Benjamin Netanyahu, her rival on the (yet farther) right?

More than most, this is a war good for, as the song says, absolutely nothing. But there may be lessons we can draw from it – about the post-Bush era. Everyone knows that the Bush government, from the Commander-in-Chief on up, lacks vision, strategic understanding and competence, and that it has no moral depth whatsoever. But the world is full of people who hope that Obama will be better. That he remains wedded to his “one President at a time” mantra in the face of such atrocities does not bode well. Obamamaniacs would do well to inquire of their idol whether he too is so much in the thrall of shortsighted, political exigencies that he will give a free pass to almost anything Israel does, no matter how monstrous.

Friday, January 2, 2009

Knowing Better

When it comes to the U.S. role in the world, I believe Obama knows better than he’s let on from the beginning of his campaign, and that he knows better than the Clintonites (and Clinton) he’s (re)empowered. They’ve been so opportunistic for so long that if any of them ever knew better, they long ago forgot. I concede, though, that I have no evidence for my belief about Obama; if there is any, he’s kept it close to his chest.

I also believe that Obama’s foreign policy will be essentially like the foreign policy of his dreadful (but “competent”) appointees, and therefore not very different from Cheney’s and Bush’s. Our corporate and military elites and our powerful interest groups -- not just the “Israel Right or Wrong Lobby” but, also the one that upholds the insanity of U.S. policy towards Cuba -- will see to it. [Is it not odd how archaic the expression “military industrial complex” seems now that American “industry” has all but, literally and figuratively, gone south!] Just as there are limits to how much competence counts, there are limits, severe ones, to how much it matters that Obama knows better, if indeed he does.

Were there not an economic catastrophe unfolding around us, Obama’s economic and domestic policies would probably be utterly conventional too, even if, as I also believe, he knows better in that department as well. Inasmuch as the environmental catastrophes unfolding around us are less salient (and of less immediate political concern) than the economic catastrophes Bush and Company have wrought, expect Obama not to stray far from policies friendly to elite interests in that domain either, though, again, he probably knows better. Needless to say, the future is unpredictable. On the one hand, Obama and his Wall Street crew could fail to rise to the occasion. Their efforts to save capitalism from itself might turn out to be too constrained by the wishes of their corporate cronies and paymasters to do much good, notwithstanding the fact that, for now, there is a political opening to do much more. On the other hand, environmental catastrophes could become harder to ignore, forcing (or at least facilitating) far-reaching changes in policy. Or events – for example, Israel’s current and on-going assault on Palestinians in the Gaza theater of its permanent war against Palestine – could spin out of control (if, for example, it destabilizes “friendly” governments in Egypt, Jordan or Saudi Arabia). Then perhaps Obama would be able to do better, not just to know better. He might even force Israel to resign itself to its internationally recognized borders; and to dismantle the Apartheid regime it has concocted in occupied Palestine. He wouldn’t have to know very much to realize that only that will bring peace to the region. But don’t count on it.

Obama’s acquiescence in the face of the current spate of Israeli atrocities is evidence in support of my hypothesis about what the Obama presidency will be like in foreign affairs. It is also evidence for the more general claim about how little knowing better matters. The Israeli war on Gaza provides additional support.

In 2006, Israel perpetrated ghastly horrors of comparable (or perhaps even greater) dimensions in Lebanon, ostensibly to win the release of a captured soldier but also, it was clear to all from the beginning, to inflict a blow on Hezbollah; to punish it for its role years earlier in forcing Israel to vacate southern Lebanon. Everyone knows the outcome – for all the murder and mayhem, for all the blatant criminality, Israel got none of what it was after. Even the U.S., which supported Israel fully – in part because it saw the Israeli-Hezbollah conflict as a proxy war against Iran -- got none of what it wanted. Israel’s 2006 war strengthened Iranian influence in the Middle East.

One would think therefore that the Israelis would know better than to repeat 2006. They probably do. They probably understand that if they truly want “tranquility” in southern Israel, and in the rest of the country, there is one and only one way to get it, and that it is readily at hand – all they need do is end the occupation that has been on-going since 1967. But there are too many constraints on Israeli politicians to do anything of the sort, and too many constraints on American politicians, including Obama, to force them to do it, even if only to save Israel from its own counter-productive folly. So on it goes. Soon, having done all the destruction they can from the air, there will be only two alternatives for Israel: they can call a truce, restoring the status quo ante, conceding, in effect, that all the killing and maiming was in vain;, or they could escalate the killing and maiming by occupying Gaza with ground troops. After Lebanon, they must realize that would likely be spectacularly counter-productive. They must know as well that it’s what Hamas wants them to do. Hamas believes, no doubt rightly, that they are now in a position to do what Hezbollah did in 2006: they believe they can humiliate the Israeli military.

Hamas, is willing to bear the cost of an Israeli invasion for reasons having mainly to do with intra-Palestinian politics; they want to supplant the increasingly servile PLO as the political vehicle for Palestinian national aspirations. Gazans, it seems, are sufficiently desperate to go along; Israel’s blockade and continual harassment since they elected Hamas into office in an indisputably fair election saw to that. Israel will take Hamas’s bait for reasons having mainly to do with Israeli politics; because, with elections coming, the center-right Kadimah Party feels it has to best the Likud, the party of the far right, in anti-Palestinian militance. The U.S. will go along for reasons having mainly to do with the influence of the Israel lobby, no matter whether the President is Bush or Obama. And the “moderate” Arab states will continue to provide Israel with tacit support for reasons having to do with the perceived interests of their corrupt, ruling elites.

But the outcome is clear for everyone who knows better (and there must be many such people in all the contending camps). As in the Bush war against Iraq, the main beneficiary will be Iran. I don’t particularly bemoan that result; as well them as any of the others. And I rather like the fact that the perturbations in world order that the Bush government’s adventurism in Iraq and Afghanistan have unleashed are so thoroughly, and ironically, counter-productive.

The problem, though, is that with militarily dominant powers, like the United States and Israel, defeat is seldom salutary – because, as in Lebanon in 2006 and as in Iraq now, it is seldom obvious enough to change domestic perceptions in a way that would force policy changes. Most Americans today actually believe that the “surge” has worked and therefore that the U.S. has won or is winning the Iraq War. Not only is this obviously false; it is plain that, in reality, if not in its media-driven representation, the U.S. has conceded defeat; indeed, that it has de facto surrendered. Rather than argue this point myself, I will conclude by quoting from the opening paragraphs of Patrick Cockburn’s excellent account in the December 18 London Review of Books. It reveals the gap between appearance and reality as vividly and concisely as can be.

It also shows that while knowing better is seldom a force for good, being clueless can be even worse. The perpetrators of the Iraq War are moral monsters -- guilty of war crimes, crimes against humanity and crimes against the peace. They deserve to be brought to justice; something Obama shows no sign of doing. But there is a certain justice in the fact that their machinations produced precisely the opposite of the outcome they envisioned:

Thus Coburn: “On 27 November the Iraqi parliament voted by a large majority in favour of a security agreement with the US under which its 150,000 troops will withdraw from Iraqi cities, towns and villages by 30 June next year and from all of Iraq by 31 December 2011. The Iraqi government will take over military responsibility for the Green Zone in Baghdad, the heart of American power in Iraq….Private security companies will lose legal immunity, US military operations will only be carried out with Iraqi consent. No US military bases will remain after the last American troops leave in 2011 and in the interim the US military is banned from carrying out attacks on other countries from within Iraq.”

If those are not surrender terms, then what is! Cockburn continues: “The Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA), signed after eight months of rancorous negotiations, is categorical and unconditional. America’s bid to act as the world’s only super-power and to establish quasi-colonial control of Iraq, an attempt that began with the invation of 2003, has ended in failure.” And he then points out that “…Even Iran, which had denounced the first drafts of the SOFA, fearing that any agreement would enshrine a permanent US presence in Iraq, now says that it will officially back the new security pact….a sure sign that American’s main rival in the Middle East sees the accord as marking the end of the occupation and the end f any notion of Iraq being used as a launching-pad for military assaults on its neighbors.”

Morally and strategically, would it have been any better had Bush and Cheney and their band of neo-cons known better? Perhaps. But, with peace candidate Obama on board for Israel’s predations in Gaza and eager to escalate Bush’s Afghanistan War, it isn’t all that clear.

Monday, December 29, 2008

Pelosiites: Worse than Bush

George Bush is out to lunch, but his government has at least had the decency to “ask” Israel to try not to kill too many civilians in Gaza with its bombs, as if that were possible in the most densely populated area in the world. Par for the course, and criminally reprehensible -- especially since Israel’s latest murderous assault would never have happened unless the United States had acquiesced.

However, “liberal” Democrats are even worse. All they can think to do is mouth off about Israel’s right of “self-defense” – against what had been a minor annoyance (homemade rockets lobbed into a small part of southern Israel, by a people staggering under the yoke of an occupation so brutal that it would be ruled a crime against humanity, if only the United States would get out of the way of international tribunals). Nancy Pelosi, true to form, leads the way. God, if She existed, could not have created a more base and servile creature. She’s been joined by Steny Hoyer, Harry Reid and others. Even Obama, vacationing in Hawaii, has chimed in in his Rorschach way – having David Axelrod repeat the Democratic catechism about how important the American-Israel “special relationship” is. He did not bother to add what everybody knows: that it’s special only to ethnic chauvinists and “morally challenged” religious fanatics – in other words, to his party’s paymasters and to the godly nincompoops he’s trying to win over with a little help from his friends (of the Rick Warren persuasion). Lesser evil party indeed!

Obama, Where's Your Vaunted "Judgment" Now That We Need It?

Yes, we know there’s “only one President at a time,” though he’s more than usually gone missing (not that anybody really minds!), and we know about the Israel lobby. We know too how, where the “Holy Land” is concerned, our political class and media insist on the “moral equivalence” of occupiers and their victims – in plain violation of common sense and elementary decency. Even so, the Israeli assault on Gaza, now in its third day, is so horrendously disproportionate, so thoroughly out of “humanitarian” bounds, that Obama’s silence in the face of it borders on Bush level morality. When the Rorschach Man becomes President, it will be up to us to force him to force Israel to join the community of civilized states. But now is not too soon for us to do our best to force the President-elect, the apostle of “change we can believe in,” to speak out – particularly with an Israeli ground invasion, an Anschluss likely to devastate both sides, in the offing.

Sunday, December 28, 2008

More Wars Ahead?

With an inspiring speech of unusual eloquence in the offing and with Lincolnesque symbolism abounding, Obama’s inauguration should surpass even that Grant Park moment on election night – especially as the fact registers that, at last, we are free from further depredations emanating from the wretched House of Bush. The entire world will rejoice.

But, even as celebratory thoughts multiply, there is cause for concern. Eight years of Bush misrule have left Obama with multiple, inter-related disasters to confront. It’s not just “the economy stupid,” catastrophic as the economic situation now is. There is also the harm done to our liberties and to the rule of law, environmental problems to address and much more. Most of all, there are those two on-going Bush wars – at least one of which Obama, formerly “the peace candidate,” intends to ratchet up several notches – proving that he too can act in dumb, counter-productive ways when “national security” is involved.

In the past few days, however, it has become clear that the outlook for peace is even worse than this because two more wars are looming. The United States is not directly involved in either, not yet; but it is a major cause of both.

There is first of all the growing likelihood of a war between India and Pakistan – both of them nuclear powers. All American presidents, going back to Jimmy Carter, helped conjure political Islam into being and Hindus have long had their own variation on the theme, but it took George W. Bush to turn Pakistan into a powder keg and to make war with India likely. Do Obama and his team of Clintonites have a clue about how to navigate this maelstrom? It remains to be seen.

Conflicts between India and Pakistan may be beyond the reach of any American government to resolve, even if there is now a window of opportunity, as Indians and Pakistanis compete to demonstrate good will by “winning one” for Obama. On the other hand, it is entirely within the means of any American government to restrain Israel as it embarks on yet another war; all that is required is a credible threat to withdraw that open-ended blank check American governments have given them almost since the inception of the state. For keeping Israel at peace, the problem is our politics, not our leverage. This too is a cause for concern.

Ever since Hamas took effective control of Gaza, Israel has done everything in its power to make life intolerable for the people there, turning an occupied territory into a besieged open-air prison. No wonder that there is armed resistance! The remarkable thing is how little there has been – just a few, mostly harmless, rockets lobbed into southern Israel. Now, though, it seems that Hamas feels strong enough to want to draw Israel into a ground war, not to defeat it outright – that would be impossible – but to humiliate it, as it was humiliated, at least twice in recent years, by Hezbollah in Lebanon. Thus they have intensified the still mostly harmless rocket lobbing. Count on Israel to find the bait irresistible. Yesterday’s murderous “shock and awe” bombing raid, killing some 240 people according to the latest reports, may just be intended, stupidly and counter-productively, as a retaliation. More likely, it is a prelude to a ground war. Who knows what disasters that will bring, especially if things go poorly for Israel, as they most likely will – if not in the (re)conquest, then in the post-conquest occupation. Are Obama and his band of Clintonites up for dealing with that war too? They won’t do right by the Palestinians, at least not intentionally; that would be asking too much. But maybe, just maybe, they can find it within themselves to save Israel from itself by imposing a semblance of a just, durable and respectful peace. There’s so far no sign of it.

But for the Israel lobby with its Jewish and fundamentalist Protestant wings, saving Israel from itself would be child’s play -- easier by far than saving capitalism from itself, the task that, thanks to Bush, the Wall Street flunkies Obama has (re)empowered may have no choice but to attempt. It is ironic that there is so much less domestic resistance to breaking with Reaganite-Clintonite orthodoxy than there is to holding Israel back. It just goes to show how, when in dire enough straits, capitalists will willingly abandon their convictions to save their asses. Believers in manifest destiny and divine providence, not to mention ethnic supremacy, are less disposed to forsake ideologically driven ambitions.

So in addition to everything else, Obama may find two more wars on his plate. Will he and his “competent” cabinet be up to dealing with so much so soon? Or will he stumble from the outset, bringing the Obama high crashing down even before memories of Inauguration Day fade? I hope I’m wrong, but my money is on the latter prospect.

Friday, April 11, 2008

Hurrah for Jimmy Carter (Again)!

Jimmy Carter has demonstrated, yet again, that, where Israel is concerned, a Democrat who would dare state the obvious or take obviously worthwhile initiatives must be at least a septuagenarian and harbor no political ambitions. This was the case when he pointed out that Israel has imposed an Apartheid system on occupied Palestine, a point many Israelis would concede. And it is the case again with his announcement that he will meet next week in Syria with Khaled Meshal, the leader of Hamas. According to a March poll published in the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, 64% of Israelis favor direct talks with Hamas. Why not? The siege of Gaza is not only politically and morally wrong (after all, Hamas won an indisputably free and fair election); it’s also a transparently failed policy – as European Union leaders and even top retired Israeli and American government officials concede. The Israeli blockade has created a severe humanitarian crisis, turning Gaza into an open air prison. One would think that the horror – directly affecting over a million and a half people -- would sway even the rankest of opportunists. But Democrats are worse than that. The Israel lobby will not countenance talks with Hamas until it recognizes Israel’s “right to exist,” not just in practice (as it already has) but in servile words (similar to those that the United States and Israel finally wrung out of the Palestinian Authority). As the lobby goes, so go Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama. Once again, the POP, the Party of Pusillanimity, shows its colors.

As befits the lesser evil party, Clinton’s and Obama’s statements on the Carter initiative have so far been less loathsome than John McCain’s. They’ve only said they “disagree” with Carter, not that they actively oppose what he’s trying to do. Needless to say, both Clinton and Obama know better. You don’t get as far as they’ve gotten by being stupid; only Republicans can do that. But, as Abba Eban might have said, the Clintons “never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity” to do the right thing, so long as the constituencies they pander to or the moneyed interests that support them object. That Hillary would distance herself, again, from Carter is therefore not surprising. Obama’s case is more complicated. Before he embarked upon a national political career, his position on Israel/Palestine seems to have been borderline reasonable. I’m not aware of any outright condemnation of the clear illegality of the Israeli occupation or of Israel’s failure to live up to the obligations of occupying powers under international law. But there is evidence that Obama expressed sympathy for Palestinian suffering. Watch for the Clintons and then the Republicans to use that bit of his past against him, and watch him then list even more egregiously towards the Morally Abominable Zone the Clintons inhabit.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Double Standard? Better Ask Hillary (and Barack and John)

When Benazir Bhutto was assassinated, the Democratic candidates were all over it. Hillary all but declared Benazir her soul mate. I suppose that paragon of foreign policy “experience” knew how corrupt Benazir’s government had been, but no matter – the corporate and corporate friendly media (NPR) proclaimed her “pro-American,” and Hillary could count on nobody knowing anything more. John Edwards was on the phone to General Musharraf, telling him to hold elections as soon as he could. General Musharraf has fairly bad press these days in the Land of the Free, so it’s OK to lean on him. Obama, who had already said he would violate Pakistani sovereignty should it be necessary to fight “terror” had some unkind words for the General too. On the other hand, when Israel cut off nearly all power to the occupied Gaza Strip, the latest outrage in a cascade of violations of international morality and law, there was not a peep out of any of them. Israel had to back down slightly thanks to international pressure. But the pressure came from human rights organizations and the EU; not the U.S. government or its “opposition” party. Neither was there the slightest expression of joy or relief when resistance fighters in Gaza ripped a hole through the “security” wall Israel had constructed on Gaza’s Egyptian border, allowing besieged Gazans the chance to enter Egypt for necessary supplies. It’s not news but it bears repeating: on Israel/Palestine, the Democrats are about as bad as can be. This is one area where they’re not even a lesser evil. Christian Zionists may gravitate towards the party of Preacher Huckabee, but the Democratic candidates, the electable ones anyway, and the Democrats in Congress, like their Republican colleagues, are owned by the Israel lobby. Won’t somebody break through the media embargo by asking Hillary and the others about it!